The play
A richly furnished, if somewhat conventional, drawing-room serves as a background. Pictures, hangings, rugs, bric-a-brac, books, all indicate that taste and discretion have been exercised in their selection, but it is evident, also, that the family life is lived elsewhere, and that this room, like certain tables in boarding-house dining-rooms, is reserved for transient guests. The chill impression given by the careful exactness of every detail is somewhat modified, however, by the cheery crackle of a wood fire, and by the shaded lights, whose rays soften, even while they illumine, the mathematical precision of the room.
PHYLLIS ARLINGTON, a slender, supple girl, whose dreamy grey eyes, sensitive nostrils, and softly moulded chin bespeak an impressionable nature—an indication somewhat contradicted, it is true, by the firmness of her lips—sits near a table on the left, occasionally taking a few stitches in the embroidery which lies, for the most part, in her lap. The lamp-light, filtering through a daffodil shade, falls upon her white-wool gown and adds a glint to her fair hair, which is neither bright enough to be golden nor dark enough to be brown.
To ROBERT CHALMERS, a vigorous, resolute, practical young fellow who lounges among the pillows of a divan on the right, she seems a delectable vision, and his eyes pay constant, eager homage, the while his slower lips temporise to suit her mood.
[continuing an argument] Well, Kipling may be all that you say, but to me he seems deplorably lacking in delicacy and idealism.
I fancy that life in India may not be conducive to the development of either of those qualities; but he's keen and direct, with an apparently inexhaustible fund of humour and a command of the English language that is simply marvellous! Moreover, he never goes into mawkish, morbid analysis of the commonplace, nor does he write unhealthy books which—to use his own words—"deal with people's insides from the point of view of men who have no stomachs."
[laughing] Rob! You quote Kipling as other people quote the Bible, and you have an appropriate text for any occasion.
[taking a book from a small table near him] Well, one can't open one of his books without finding something worth reading. Listen to this, for instance. [Reads.] "How can a man who has never married; who cannot be trusted to pick up at sight a moderately sound horse; whose head is hot and upset with visions of domestic felicity, go about the choosing of a wife? He cannot see straight or think straight if he tries; and the same disadvantages exist in the case of a girl's fancies. But when mature, married, and discreet people arrange a match between a boy and a girl, they do it with a view to the future, and the young couple live happily ever afterward. As everybody knows." [Laughs.] What a jolly, sarcastic beggar he is!
Does that impress you as being sarcasm?
[lowering the book to stare at her] Great Scott! Does that impress me as being sarcasm! What else could it be?
Well, I know one can't be too certain of Kipling's opinions, but at any rate, he might mean that. Many people would agree with him.
[returning to the perusal of his book] Humph!
Now, for instance, that has been for a long time a favourite theory of mine, and if the day ever comes when I care enough for a man to want to marry him I shall refer the matter to a committee of our friends and abide by their decision.
[hotly, throwing the book aside] Do you mean to say that if you loved a man you would permit any one else to decide for you whether or not you should marry him?
[calmly] I mean precisely that. I should deem myself prejudiced and consequently unfit to decide so important a question.
[leaning forward and speaking argumentatively] But, Phyllis, can't you see how absurd it is? The idea of expecting—or permitting—any one else to decide for you a question that concerns you so vitally—a matter so purely personal.
[very earnestly] That's just the point! It does concern me so vitally that I can't be expected to look at it from a rational point of view. I am too near it; I have no perspective. And I'm surprised to hear you speak of marriage as purely a personal matter, Rob.
But no one else can know your heart, so how——
[quickly] For that very reason, anybody else's judgment would be better than mine. What right have two people to say: "Because we love each other we will marry, be the consequences what they may"? That kind of love has been well defined as "an egotism of two."
[rising impatiently] And in its place you would establish an intellectual companionship which, after it has been investigated and approved by your cold-blooded committee, you will allow to expand—perhaps—into a calm affection. Cupid with a microscope! [He goes to the fireplace and stands impatiently rubbing his hands before the blaze.]
[resignedly resuming her embroidery] Indeed, you misunderstand me! But Mrs. Treavor says that in questions relating to marriage, people think far too much of their own selfish desires, and far too little of the effect of their indulgence upon Humanity.
[drily] Did Mrs. Treavor marry to benefit humanity?
[sadly] No; and she has realised her mistake and suffered bitterly for it.
[somewhat quizzically, turning toward her] Did she tell you that, too?
Oh, no! How can you be so unfair to her, Rob? But one who knows her well can see how bravely she struggles to make the most of what life has left possible for her.
[standing with his back to the fireplace, hands behind him] Well, it's left a good deal. Joe Treavor is one of the straightest, manliest fellows I know.
[impatiently] Oh, yes, I dare say—from a man's point of view! But so lacking in perception, in—in——
[bluntly] Well, in what?
Oh, in everything that a woman like Mrs. Treavor needs!
Why, then, did she marry him?
[triumphantly] That's just it! She loved him—and idealised him—and so, of course, she couldn't see that he was of too coarse a fibre to satisfy her soul's needs.
[returning to the divan] Her soul fiddlesticks!
[indignantly] Rob! If you only knew Mrs. Treavor, you'd understand how fine and strong and womanly she is, and what a perpetual sacrifice her life has been.
[taking up his book again] Perhaps I should; and yet—I'm only a man, you know.
[quickly] Yes, but such a—— [She stops, in confusion.]
[again throwing book aside and going toward her eagerly] Yes? You were about to say——?
[shyly] You're so different from other men! So reasonable—so much more sympathetic—so—so—oh, you know!
[standing behind her chair] Phyllis, am I different enough to—to——
[with an effort, faintly] To what, Rob?
[bending over her] To win you, dear? I love you, Phyllis! I know I'm not a poet and I don't understand lots of your theories, but—I love you! [PHYLLIS hides her face from him. After a pause, he almost whispers:] Phyllis!
Yes?
[tenderly] Are you offended? Why don't you answer me?
[archly] Did you ask anything?
[eagerly taking her hand] Don't trifle, dear! I ask everything! Your love—and you! Do you love me, Phyllis? A little?
[softly] Yes—a little.
Phyllis! [He tries to put his arms about her, but she springs up and eludes him.] Really—really, you love me?
[keeping a chair between them] Really, really, I—love you! [He moves around the chair and she retreats behind the divan, saying hastily:] But you must behave very well if you expect me to continue to do so. For example [he advances; she backs away], you must not be—greedy!
[at right of divan, protestingly] But, dearest!
[at left of divan, teasingly] Well—dearest?
[pleadingly] Phyllis, dear, don't tease—now!
Very well; I'll be as serious as you choose, if you'll promise——
Yes?
To treat me as a prisoner of war and not as—a target!
[reproachfully] A prisoner?
[very sweetly] Have I not surrendered? [He moves quickly toward her, but as she withdraws he steps back.]
Very well; I promise. Come out from behind your fortifications. [She sits on the divan.]
[pensively, after a pause] I wonder what Mrs. Treavor will say?
[ardently] What matter? I'm content to know what you have said. [He draws a chair very near her and sits.] Phyllis [persuasively], when will you marry me?
[in alarm] Marry you! Oh—why—let's not talk about that!
Phyllis! What do you mean?
[breathlessly] Why—you know—there's something to—to consider first.
[bewildered] Why, what? What is there? Is anybody's consent required? We're orphans, and of age.
Yes, but I wonder if—if they—will let us—marry?
[still puzzled] They? Who in thunder are "they"?
Why, my friends, you know, to whom I must submit the matter.
[relieved] Oh, your people! Why, of course they will! I suppose I must ask your uncle, as a matter of form, for your hand, but that'll be all right! Both he and your aunt know that I love you, and they've been very kind to me.
Oh, Uncle Jerry! Of course he won't object! And if he did, I could coax him out of it in five minutes. Ah! Ah! [She holds up a warning hand as he moves impulsively toward her and slips away to the farther end of the divan. He sits beside her.] And Auntie would agree with Uncle Jerry. She always does.
Well, then, who else is there whom we must consult?
[faintly] The—the committee.
The committee! What committee? Surely, Phyllis, you don't intend—you can't intend to refer this matter to—oh, pshaw! Of course you don't!
[more firmly] But I do, Rob! I must! Don't you see? We're in no position to judge whether our marriage would be best for us—best for Humanity.
Why aren't we?
Because we love each other. [As he tries to clasp her in his arms, she shrinks from him.] No, no, Rob! You mustn't! Indeed, you mustn't, until—until we are certain.
[gravely] Aren't you certain now, Phyllis?
That I care, yes—but not that I dare marry you. Our judgment is so warped now by our love for each other that it's impossible for us to be entirely rational. [She rises, speaking impressively.] But so much depends upon the wise solution of this problem, not only for us but for society, that we must invoke the aid of earnest, serious minds, and rely absolutely upon their conclusions.
[quietly, rising also] Far be it from me to question the wisdom of the East, but it will be some years, I fancy, before that eminently Oriental idea takes root and flourishes in the Occidental mind. Why, Phyllis, that's the philosophy of India, where happy marriages, as we understand them, are absolutely unknown.
[reverently] Mrs. Treavor says that no one can estimate the psychic influence of the Home. Its potentiality is limitless; its consequences so far-reaching as to be incalculable; and if the elements combining in its atmosphere are not well balanced, only evil can result.
But, Phyllis, dear——
She says, too, that only by awakening the cosmic consciousness in man, and a sense of his personal relation to all mental causation, can we hope to establish ideal conditions and become quite free. And so we must enter reverently into the realm of cause and abide by its laws, Rob.
[pacing to and fro] How are you going to ascertain all this, Phyllis?
[somewhat reluctantly] Well, I suppose one never can be absolutely certain, but [resuming her seat on the divan] we must do all we can to find out, mustn't we, Rob?
Oh, I suppose we must! But——
Just a moment, please. We'll name a committee—two of my friends and two of yours—and they will select a fifth person [ROBERT dubiously shakes his head], and then we shall let them decide for us whether or not we are really suited to each other and may marry with reasonable safety.
[sitting beside her and taking her hand] See here, Phyllis, listen to me. You're talking nonsense, dear. No one could decide that as well as we can. [She vainly tries to withdraw her hand. He continues earnestly.] You know me well. I have loved you for years, and I have kept nothing back from you that could influence your love for me. You don't doubt that I love you, do you? Do you, Phyllis?
No.
Nor my ability to care for you?
Oh, no!
Then why tantalise me? Say that you'll marry me—soon!
[rising, almost crying, and pulling her hand away] I can't Rob! I can't! It wouldn't be right!
[very gravely] You insist upon appointing this absurd committee? Upon laying bare the sweetest, most sacred feeling in our lives, and inviting those people to dissect it, examine it, and pronounce upon its quality?
[obstinately] I do!
[rising] Evidently I have laboured under a grave misapprehension. I gathered the impression, somehow, that you cared for me—that you might even love me.
[piteously] Oh, I do! I do!
Then why in the name of all that's reasonable——
Mrs. Treavor says——
Hang Mrs. Treavor!
[rising] Robert!
[bowing stiffly] I beg your pardon.
[with dignity] Mrs. Treavor says that our hearts are dangerously deceptive, and that it's only after we have suffered and suffered that we dare trust to their impulses.
And so you are making me "suffer and suffer" that you may be certain of me. Is that it?
[simply] No, dear. But I know so little of sorrow—my life has been so smooth and so happy—and we have been so—so happy—together—that I can't trust myself. And I must know that I'm doing you no wrong before I promise to marry you.
[stepping quickly to her side and taking her hands] Dear little woman, how could you do me a wrong?
[gently] You don't seem to understand, Rob, that there are very grave ethical responsibilities to consider. And then, we've said nothing yet of the effect of the subconscious mind which, when it is untrained as [hesitatingly]—as yours is, dear—may exert a very baleful influence. Some one has said that there are a great many very excellent people who are not at all excellent for each other, and we may be among them.
[positively] Well, we're not! However, I suppose I must submit, though I think it's arrant nonsense—and worse. It's sacrilegious!
Oh, Rob!
But we'll be even that, if it pleaseth my lady. Come, we'll sit here and select our committee [she permits herself to be led to the divan, where they sit]; and—oh, I say! You must let me keep possession of that hand, you know, as a sort of—er—retaining fee, to quiet my scruples about this jury business. So! Now, you begin.
I'll name one, and then you name one.
[kissing her hand] All right. Fire away!
Mrs. Treavor.
[protestingly] Now, see here, Phyllis, that's hardly fair! Mrs. Treavor belongs to the ultra-anti-masculine wing of the woman movement, and opposes marriage on principle. She is, no doubt, an excellent woman, but——
[fervently] She's a noble woman, Rob, with such profound soul-depth!
H'm! Well—I'm not so sure about the soul-depth, girlie. She doesn't seem to have soul-depth enough to appreciate her husband, who is one of the finest, cleanest, most all-round good fellows I've ever known—and I know him well. She doesn't seem to have soul-depth enough to realise that that puny, spindle-legged boy of hers needs more of her attention than her clubs and classes. She doesn't seem to feel [ROBERT warms as he proceeds, and PHYLLIS withdraws her hand] that her husband and son are freezing to death in the extremely rarefied atmosphere of the home that she ought to make warm and cheery and wholesome, while she floats about in a transcendental haze, lecturing to a lot of sentimental women [PHYLLIS indignantly rises and crosses to the other side of the room] about how to satisfy the "soul hunger" of humanity—humanity with a capital H!
[coldly] I knew that you couldn't be just to Mrs. Treavor, Rob, but I didn't expect you to be brutal. She is my dearest friend; the woman upon whose judgment I most rely.
[springing up and excitedly pacing to and fro] Yes, and she's the woman who's responsible for all this foolishness! She fancies herself misunderstood and unappreciated, and prates about her wasted life; she inveighs against men and against marriage, and teaches good, sweet, sensible girls like you to believe that you can't trust to the promptings of your own pure hearts——
But, Rob, list——
And that there's something in her hazy, remote, bloodless philosophy that will atone to you for the sacrifice of your sacred human yearning for love and all that it brings to a woman! I know her kind, confound 'em, and they're all dangerous!
[with freezing dignity] You forget yourself, Robert! We are not discussing Mrs. Treavor. She is my choice for one member of our committee. [She crosses the room with stately tread.]
[pausing in his walk for a moment] You will not withdraw her name, Phyllis?
[coldly] Certainly not.
She returns to the seat she first occupied, near the lamp, and makes a pretence of continuing her embroidery, but her glance furtively follows him. He resumes his impatient walk. Of a sudden he pauses behind her chair, his eyes widen and brighten with an illuminating thought; he puckers up his lips as if to whistle, throws back his head in a silent laugh, and then, again reducing his features to gravity, crosses slowly to the divan and throws himself once more among its pillows.
[deliberately] Very well, I accept Mrs. Treavor—though I don't like her [PHYLLIS prepares to be affable again], and I'll name—er—let me see—Duncan Graham!
[in consternation] Rob!
[in a tone of mild surprise] Well?
[indignantly] That crusty old bachelor?
[judicially] Why not? Man of excellent judgment, Graham. Scotch, you know. So cool and hard-headed.
Pig-headed, you mean!
And eminently modern, I should say.
[with heat] Yes, too modern! He seems to regard married men as victims of untoward circumstance, and he congratulates engaged girls! Horrid old thing!
[with quiet dignity] Phyllis, you are speaking of a man for whom I have the greatest admiration.
[very erect, two bright spots of colour burning in her cheeks] I don't care! He is horrid! Why, Rob, he'll make no end of a fuss!
A fuss?
Yes; he'll be sure to raise a lot of objections. He thought Will Forbes was so foolish to marry Mollie Turner, and she's such a sweet, dear girl, too!
[with amusement] Yes, I know. He even tried to argue Forbes out of the notion, and when he failed he said that the worst of congenital idiocy was its hopelessness.
[indignantly] I don't see anything funny about that! I suppose he'll go about saying that you're a congenital idiot, too! He told me at the Terry's dinner the other night that he thought you had a great future before you, if [with withering scorn] you didn't marry too soon. And then he quoted that silly old saw, "A young man married is a man that's marred." Spiteful old thing!
[to himself] The deuce he did! Bull's-eye, by Jove. [To her, carelessly:] Yes, I know that to be his opinion. That's the reason I chose him. You know, Graham sees so clearly all the obstacles that matrimony puts in a man's way—the added responsibility [counting them off deliberately on his fingers], the loss of personal liberty, the petty social duties, the possible—er—nagging, the narrowed horizon, the contracted environment, the curtailed opportunities, the——
[hysterically, rising] You needn't go on, Mr. Chalmers! I've heard quite enough! I wouldn't for anything in the world entail such sacrifice upon you!
[mildly] My dear little girl, how excitable you are!
[sits suddenly, tapping on the table with her finger-tips] I am not your dear little girl! And I'm not in the least excited!
But, Phyllis, be calm a moment and listen to reason.
[again springing to her feet] Reason! Reason! That's like a man! You all care so much more for what you call "reason," and for practical, sordid considerations than you do for our happiness! [Turns her back upon him.]
[suppressing a smile] But I understood that this committee was to be formed for eminently practical purposes, to suggest and consider the objections to our marriage that we couldn't be expected, under the circumstances, to discover.
[over her shoulder] You seem to have no difficulty in discovering them!
But Graham could think of so many more! You see, he's not hampered by his love for you. [PHYLLIS sniffs disdainfully. ROBERT lazily leans back among the cushions.] Now, that's settled. Who's your next candidate?
[turning upon him suddenly] Do I understand that you will not withdraw Duncan Graham's name?
Certainly I'll not. Why should I?
You want that crabbed, dyspeptic, pessimistic, stubborn, detestable old Scotchman making his cynical comments on—on our love for each other?
[slowly rising and moving toward her, speaking solemnly and impressively] But you remember that Mrs. Treavor says that love between a man and a woman is, of itself, an insurmountable subjective obstacle, evanescent in its very nature, and paralysing to the conversation of soul energy; and that only when these subjective distortions are cast aside, and the higher potentialities of the spirit are educed, can the submerged mentality become transcendentally greater in scientific idealism, and the ego, vibrating to a dominant note in the thought-atmosphere, become a finited spirit, potentially whole. [To himself, ruefully:] I'm afraid I got that mixed!
[who has been staring at him in amazement and consternation, runs past him and throws herself, weeping, upon the divan] Oh, Rob! Rob! Rob!
Impulsively, he starts to comfort her, but checks himself, shakes his head, thrusts his hands resolutely into his trousers' pockets, and stands looking down at her.
[very tenderly] Phyllis, shall we give up this idea? Shall we put our faith in our love for each other and—[smiling slightly] chance it?
[rising, wrathful, tearful, defiant] No! No! No! We can't give it up! But you must withdraw Duncan Graham. I will not have him on that committee! You understand, Rob?
[thoughtfully, to himself] Now for one big, brutal bluff! [He turns toward her, speaking sternly.] Phyllis, listen to me. I have yielded thus far to your folly because I hoped you'd see the absurdity of your position. [She makes an imperious gesture, which he ignores.] Your conduct shows me that my hope is vain. Now we'll decide this question at once, if you please. You know that I love you. You know what my circumstances are, financially and socially, and what your position as my wife would be. You say that you love me. If you love me, you'll marry me. [He takes out his watch.] I will give you five minutes in which to decide whether or not you'll marry me within three months. If, at the end of five minutes, you have not decided, I shall go away—and I shall not return. [PHYLLIS is defiant.] . . . One minute. [PHYLLIS taps her foot and clasps and unclasps her hands.] . . . Two minutes. [PHYLLIS fumbles for her handkerchief.] . . . Three minutes. [PHYLLIS furtively wipes her eyes.] . . . Four minutes. [PHYLLIS drops among the pillows and weeps.] . . . Five minutes! [He closes the watch with a snap and returns it to his pocket.] Phyllis [tenderly], will you marry me? [PHYLLIS sobs. After a slight pause, ROBERT walks rapidly to the door, where he turns and looks back at her.] Phyllis? . . . Good night. [Exit ROBERT.]
As soon as the curtain falls behind him, PHYLLIS sits up, listens to his departing steps, and springs to her feet.
[calling] Rob! Rob! Oh, Rob! [As he appears in the doorway, she retreats a few steps.]
[politely] You called? [She nods and sobs.] You wished to say?
[faintly, struggling with her sobs] I'll—I'll withdraw—Mrs. Treavor's—name—from that—that committee,—if—if you'll withdraw——
Well?
If you'll withdraw—Duncan Graham's.
[entering] Oh, well, that's fair. Of course I will. But, really, [slowly drawing nearer to her], I don't see the need of any other committee, if—if—if we——
[beaming, expectant, joyous] Why, neither do I, you old goose!
She stretched out her hands to him, and as he moves toward her with extended arms——
Quick Curtain.
Her Neighbour's Creedby Margaret CameronA churchgoing wife who won't dine out on Good Friday talks herself into a concert.
The Kleptomaniacby Margaret CameronA scatterbrained wife who has lost her purse sets the police and a gossip reporter on the woman beside her at a recital, who is coming to dinner.
Miss Doulton's Orchidsby Margaret CameronA box of orchids sent to an actress convinces three women that the men they love are faithless.
A Pipe of Peaceby Margaret CameronA collector's wife trades her husband's beloved meerschaum pipe for a fake antique chair.