The play
A room in the sheriff’s house which is used for conferences. At the rear is a door into the hall, at the left a door leads to an adjoining room. There is also a door at the right, going to the corridor which connects this house with the jail.
LAWYER and PRISONER are found in heated conversation. The prisoner, an attractive young man, is seated, and has just turned away from the LAWYER, irritated.
Do you know that murder is no laughing matter?
Well, was I laughing?
[Shoots it at him.] Where were you on the night of October 25? [PRISONER sits like one who never means to speak again.] Your silence shields a woman’s honor. Do you know what’s going to be said of you? You’re going to be called old-fashioned! [A worried look flits over the prisoner’s face.] A man will not tell where he is because it involves a woman’s honor! How quaint! [In a different voice.] Say, do you think she’s worth it? [PRISONER rises angrily.] Yes, get red in the face, I should think you would. Blush. Blush for shame. Shame of having loved a woman who’d let a man face death to shield her own honor!
You don’t know what you’re talking about.
It’s just like a woman, the cowards. That’s what I most despise in women. Afraid they won’t be looked upon as the pure noble sensitive souls they spend their lives trying to make us believe they are. Sickening!
There are things you don’t understand.
Oh, yes, I do. I suppose she’s got a husband. I suppose he’d divorce her. Then she wouldn’t be asked out to tea quite so often. Good Lord--die for something real!
You and I have different ideals, Mr. Foster. There are things we don’t discuss.
There are things we have to discuss. If you insist upon this romantic course, then at least we will have to get something out of that.
What do you mean?
Simply that public feeling has got to swing toward you or the jury will say you murdered Erwalt. If we can’t have an alibi, let us by all means have a hero!
[Outraged.] Have you given out a story to the newspapers?
[Drawing paper from his pocket.] Very delicately done. “A life for a life.” Isn’t that moving? “While Gordon Wallace languishes in his cell, some woman is safe in a shielded home. Charged with the murder of John Erwalt, young Wallace fails to cut his chain of circumstantial evidence with an alibi. Where was Gordon Wallace on the night of October 25? He maintains a dogged silence. Behind that silence rests a woman’s honor”--and so on, at some length.
You had no right to give out a story without my consent!
Oh, yes, I have. If I can’t get your consent for saving your life, then, my young friend, I shall save it without your consent. Pardon my rudeness.
How will this save it?
How little romantic young men know the romantic sex. Wives--including, I hope, jurors’ wives--will cry, “Don’t let that chivalrous young man die!” Women just love to have their honor shielded. It is very touching to them.
Mr. Foster, I tell you again, I dislike your attitude toward women! Laugh at me if you will, but I have respect and reverence for women. I believe it is perfectly true that men must guard them. Call me a romantic young fool if it pleases you, but I have had a mother--a sister--sweetheart. Yes, I am ready to die to shield a woman’s honor!
As he says this the door slowly opens and a woman steps in.
No! You shall not!
Quite taken aback, the men stand looking at her. She has breeding, poise--obviously she has stepped out of a world where women are shielded. She maintains a front of her usual composure, but there is an intensity--an excitement--which indicates she is feeling some big new thing. LAWYER looks from her to the PRISONER, who is staring at the WOMAN.
[To WOMAN.] Oh--you’ve come?
[Firmly, but with emotion.] I have come.
I don’t understand.
You were not willing to let him die?
No.
Good. This young man--[He pauses, embarrassed, for it does not seem a thing to say to this lady] was with you on the night of October 25?
Yes.
Why, no I wasn’t.
There is no use, Gordon, in trying to keep the lady from doing what she has apparently determined to do.
No. You cannot keep me from doing what I have determined to do.
For my part, I respect you for it. Then you are prepared to testify that on the night of October 25 Gordon Wallace was with you from twelve o’clock midnight till eight next morning?
[A little falteringly, yet fervent.] Yes.
Was with you--continuously?
Yes.
Your name is--?
He takes out his note-book.
[In distress.] Don’t give him your name! He’ll use it! I tell you this is all a mistake. I don’t know this lady. I never saw her before. [To the WOMAN.] You mustn’t do this!
[Proudly, and with relief.] I have done it!
And as I said, madam, I greatly respect you for doing it. You are, if I may say so, unlike most of your sex. Now--your name?
[This is not easy for her.] Mrs. Oscar Duncan.
And Mrs. Duncan you live at--? [A noise in the hall.] I fear some one is coming in. Will you just step in here?
He shows her into the room at the left. They hear the corridor door open and turn. A woman is coming in--rather plump, middle-aged--a pleasant, motherly looking woman. She looks from the LAWYER to the PRISONER, moves to get a better look at the young man, who becomes nervous under this scrutiny; then she seems to have it straight in her mind, nods pleasantly.
[Cheerily.] Good morning.
Good morning.
[To PRISONER.] Good morning.
[Not cheerily.] Good morning.
There was no one out there, so I just walked right in. [LAWYER nods.] I thought you might be glad to see me.
Oh--we are. [To GORDON.] Aren’t we?
I suppose I am in the right place.
Well, it is the right place for some things.
Is it the place to tell the truth about Gordon Wallace?
It seems to be.
[Very cheerfully.] Well, then, on the night of October 25 that young man--[Steps for a better look at the PRISONER] this young man--was with me.
From twelve o’clock midnight until eight next morning?
[Placidly.] From twelve o’clock midnight till eight next morning.
She takes a muffler from her bag and sits down and begins to knit.
Was with you--continuously?
Oh, certainly--continuously.
She knits serenely on.
Well--Gordon.
[Pleasantly.] It seems that mufflers get longer and longer. [Looking up at LAWYER.] Doesn’t it?
Why--perhaps they do. But--you are willing to leave your name and address?
Certainly, I’m willing to leave my name and address. What else would I be here for? Oh--but could I use the telephone first. [Rises.] It will be better to let them know that I’ll probably be late getting home for lunch.
[Is about to open door of the room in which the SHIELDED ONE is waiting.] No--there’s some one in there. Here [Going to the door at the other side of the room], I’ll show you how to get through to the jail phone.
The jail! But we’ll soon have you out of jail.
She goes, giving the young man an encouraging smile. The LAWYER steps out with her. The young man hears the rear door opening--this door into the hall has a slight squeak--starts nervously, looks around to see a young woman come in. In a keen, cool amused way she is staring at him. He turns away, petulantly hitching his chair. She moves where she can see him better, takes from her bag a newspaper picture, looks from it to him. He turns, sees what she is doing; she smiles at him. He looks like one at bay. Enter LAWYER. Sees what is going on, smiles.
On the night of October 25--?
[To LAWYER.] I understand that down here a man is about to die for a woman’s honor.
He had some such thing in mind.
[To LAWYER.] Now you can’t get away with that. Sorry to upset your plans, but the death seems uncalled for. On the night of October 25--Gordon Wallace was with me.
From twelve o’clock midnight till eight next morning?
From twelve o’clock midnight until eight next morning.
[Rather feebly.] Con-tinuously?
[In an offhand voice.] Continuously.
Well--well, Gordon, I begin to understand why you hesitated to tell the truth about that momentous night. Rise and thank the lady, Gordon; it would seem the least you could do would be to rise and
As he is saying this to GORDON, in rushes a fussily dressed hysterical woman and throws her arms around the LAWYER’S neck.
Darling! I cannot let you die for me!
[Trying to free himself.] Pardon me, madam, but
Gordon! You call me madam after that night together. Oh my beloved, when I think of those hours I lay in your arms
Pardon me, but you never lay in
I know. Ah--I understand. You pretend not to know me. You would die to shield me--but you shall not! You cannot escape me!
[Still unsuccessful in freeing himself.] Apparently not. But permit me to tell you, you are making a mistake.
No! I am not making a mistake! You shall not die for me.
I really don’t intend to--if I can help it.
Love is so beautiful. So ennobling! [Overcome with emotion, loosens her hold.] When I think of that night--October 25
Sinks into a chair.
[After settling his collar.] Well, Gordon, have you a choice? [Pause.] You see you didn’t understand women as well as you thought.
[Fiercely.] Neither did you!
The SHERIFF’S BOY comes in.
While I was over at the bank, women came.
Yes, I know.
[Looking at the two women in the room.] But more women. [PRISONER starts in terror.] Six women are out there.
Don’t let them in!
Tell the ladies we shall not need them. Thank them for coming. [BOY goes out. To PRISONER.] Well, come now. What shall we do with this embarrassment of--generosity? You see dying for a woman’s honor isn’t as easy as you might think. It even looks as though there were a sort of conspiracy against it.
I’m not going to be made a fool of.
Are you sure you can help it?
The BOY comes back, looking worried.
Some of those women won’t go away. I don’t know what to do with them.
No, it’s not a matter the young can cope with.
He goes out with the BOY. The amused young WOMAN sits looking the PRISONER over, to his embarrassment and final irritation.
So you were thinking of dying for a woman’s honor. [He says nothing.] Now do you think that’s a very nice way to treat the lady? [He turns away petulantly.] Seems to me you should think of her feelings. Have you a right to ruin her life?
[Startled into speech.] Ruin her life?
Why certainly. A life that somebody has died for is practically a ruined life. For how are you going to think of it as anything but--a life that somebody has died for? [She pulls her chair to a more confidential angle.] Did it ever strike you as funny that woman’s honor is only about one thing, and that man’s honor is about everything but that thing? [After waiting for the answer which does not come.] Now woman’s honor means woman’s virtue. But this lady for whom you propose to die has no virtue.
[Springing up.] Please be careful what you say.
I’m being very careful. I’m thinking it out just as carefully as I can. The night of October 25, or at some time previous to that, she lost her virtue, and you propose to die to keep us from knowing about this loss. Now, it has happened, hasn’t it? On the night of October 25, from twelve o’clock midnight till eight next morning continuously she lost her virtue. You aren’t dying to keep her virtuous. I fancy few lives have been laid upon that altar. But you’re dying to keep us from knowing she is what she is. Dear me, it seems rather sad.
[Controlling her tears.] It is noble beyond words.
There’s where you’re going to get your approbation.
The MOTHERLY ONE now returns from her telephoning. She looks at the SILLY WOMAN, then at the SCORNFUL ONE--these two stand looking one another up and down.
[In her amused manner.] Can it be that we are two souls with but a single thought?
[In her mothering voice.] Perhaps we are two hearts that beat as one.
They stand there a moment not knowing what to do; then, still uncertainly, they sit down, stealing glances at one another. Finally the SCORNFUL ONE smiles.
We might draw lots.
Love conquereth all things.
Even the female brain.
I wonder why you others came.
Why did you come?
Oh, I have children of my own. I thought, he’s just a nice boy, and probably she’s just some nice girl afraid of her mother. And I thought--well, now what an awful pity to let him die, or even spend a lot of time in prison. I said to myself, it would be just like a lot of men to fuss around about a woman’s honor and really let it hurt somebody. So I decided--well, I’ll go. What harm can it do me? [Resumes her knitting.] You see, I’m in the habit of trying to save lives. I do nursing--practical nursing--and I didn’t happen to be on a case just now, so I thought--well, I’ll just take this case. Some of the folks I nurse for may be shocked--but good sensible nurses aren’t so easy to get. Of course my children may be upset about it--but they’re awful nice children, and when they’re a little older probably they’ll be pleased to think their mother didn’t want a nice boy to die. [Drops her knitting.] I wonder if she will come.
Looks at the other two with new interest.
I wonder.
“She” is here.
Oh, it’s not you. You thought it was the lawyer you were with. Anyway, people who do things don’t make so much fuss about them.
[Whose interest has not been diverted.] I think she will have to come.
The door of the room into which the SHIELDED ONE was shown opens quietly and without the others being aware of it the SHIELDED ONE is standing in the doorway, bringing with her that sense of the ordered protected life out of which she has stepped.
I’m sure I don’t see how she could ever think of staying away. I hate a coward.
Some women think a great deal about their honor. I think usually it’s women who aren’t very well--or who haven’t much else to take up their time.
Impulsively the SHIELDED ONE steps forward as if to speak. Hearing her, they turn, and in their interest rise and stand looking at her.
Oh--you’ve come?
The PRISONER, who to get away from the women gives the impression of being crowded into a corner, also turns and rises.
[To SHIELDED ONE, rather crossly.] Please go away!
O-h.
Can’t you see there is no need for your staying?
[Quietly.] There is need of it.
She sits down, the other women still surveying her.
It’s true we aren’t all needed. Who will be best--? [To SCORNFUL ONE.] Tell me, why are you here?
Well, you see for myself I haven’t any honor to worry about, and haven’t had for some time. So I thought, if the sacrifice of a woman’s honor is going to save, a man’s life, let me, who have none, nobly sacrifice mine.
What do you mean, you haven’t had any honor for some time?
Oh, I haven’t had my honor around with me since I was seventeen.
[Kindly.] Do you miss it?
Well--yes; sometimes when I’m tired I might like to slump back into it. You see honor camouflages so many things--stupidity, selfishness--greed, lust, avarice, gluttony. So without it you’re almost forced to be a decent sort--and that’s sometimes wearing. [In another voice.] But I’ll tell you why I’m really here! When men begin to sob around about woman’s honor they get my goat. That lawyer--he thought he was going to get away with it. Why, woman’s honor would have died out long ago if it hadn’t been for men’s talk about it.
I suppose it really has to be kept up, as long as it gives men such noble feelings.
That man--the one when I was seventeen--he’s that sort. He would be of course. Why, this instant his eyes would become “pools of feeling” if any one were to talk about saving a woman’s honor. [Under her breath.] Gee!
[With a diffident glance at the SHIELDED ONE.] If she is here, she must be feeling quite upset. If she cares enough about her honor to have held back this long--it can’t be easy to let it go.
She’ll be better off without it.
I don’t know. You see, she’s had it quite a while. She’s used to it. I was thinking
The door opens and a brisk young woman dressed in cheap, up-to-the-minute clothes darts in. All turn and look at her, continue to stare. Something in this scrutiny becomes disconcerting.
While he was busy with the other women--I just slipped by. Is this--?
Sees the young man, now huddled in terror.
Sit down and wait your turn.
Are all of you ahead of me?
Your number seems to be five.
Number five sits down; a pause in which they continue to look at her in this unusual way--she finally rather indignantly settles her coat, her hat, assuring herself nothing is the matter with her.
You look young for this.
Well, if you’ll excuse my saying so, the same objection can’t be made to some of you.
What are you here for?
Oh, I guess I’m here for about the same reason all of you are here.
But we are here for different reasons.
Say, what are you tryin’ to put over on me? Suppose I think you’re here for your health? Or out of kindness? Or to show your great beauty? Hard-ly. Anybody not feeble-minded could dope out why you’re sitting here like owls.
Well--why?
Oh, not for money, of course.
She has horrified them all.
I’m sorry you said that.
How sordid! How desecrating!
Say--I don’t like the atmosphere of this place.
We don’t like it as well as we did.
A business proposition is a business proposition. What a man needs and can pay for
[Rising and wringing her hands.] I really must ask you--Love is so beautiful!
Well, suppose it is? What’s that got to do with it?
You seem hard for one so young.
I may be hard, but I’m not a nut.
Woman’s honor doesn’t play much part in your young life, does it? Or woman’s self-respect, either.
[Rising.] Say, you think you can sit there and insult me? I don’t know what you are, but I’ll have you know I’m an honest working girl! I heard they were going to take on another stenographer down here, but I don’t like the atmosphere of this place.
She leaves.
[Settling herself with relief.] It was a misunderstanding. Ah, life is paved with misunderstanding.
It will be said we did this for money.
Oh, a great deal will be said. If you care about what’s said you’d better follow the honest working girl out that door.
What’s said makes an awful difference in some people’s lives.
Her eyes turn toward the SHIELDED ONE.
They don’t know how much difference until they’ve heard it said.
She too looks at the SHIELDED ONE.
You get made into one thing and then it’s not easy to be another. And as the honest working girl hinted, some of us aren’t as young as--we’d like to be.
Age shouldn’t discourage one. It’s never too late to mend.
The door swings, the women look expectantly around; the unfortunate young man, whose face has been buried in his hands, looks round in terror. They wait a moment but no one comes in.
If “she” is here, and really minds losing her honor--well, she could just go home. [SILLY ONE rises, simpers, sits down again.] We can’t all lose our honor. It might do the young man more harm than good. It’s different with you--[To SCORNFUL ONE] you had an early start. And then you’ve got character. You don’t need honor to lean on.
[Breaking her silence with simple intensity.] What is woman’s honor?
A thing men talk about.
A safe corner.
A star to guide them!
[Very earnestly.] Guide them where?
Yes, where? Many a woman who’s guided hasn’t guided anywhere.
[Passionately.] Aren’t we something more than things to be noble about?
Of course what we’ve really been is kind. We have not deprived them of the pleasures of being noble. If we do it now, it will leave them in a bleak world.
[Troubled but determined.] Can’t we put something in its place, so they won’t be too desolate and yet we won’t be so
Bored.
If we could only get them noble about something else. I should really hate to take it from them entirely. It’s like giving up smoking or drinking. You have to do it gradually, and there should be something to put in its place.
If we could only think up a new vice for them.
They have all those.
Oh, I hope you women can work out some way to free us from men’s noble feelings about it! I speak for all the women of my--[Hesitates] under-world, all those others smothered under men’s lofty sentiments toward them! I wish I could paint for you the horrors of the shielded life. [Says “shielded” as if it were “shameful.”] I know you would feel something must be done to save us. After all [Growing a little wild] are we not your sisters? Our honor has been saved so many times. We are tired. And so when I read in the paper this morning that woman’s honor was being saved again
[Excitedly going to her.] Read in the paper? Then you’re not--the one?
Not that one, but
Slowly the door opens and a woman comes in--comes with a strange quiet. She droops, she has a queer passivity--she is unaccountably forceful. Gives a sense of one who has been cheated and is going to be cheated no more. She is scarcely aware of the other women. Her eyes, dead, or rather dogged with life, go to the unfortunate young man. He has turned to look at her; he is not able to look away.
[Nervously.] Are you a stenographer?
[Not interested in this.] No.
In her dogged way she advances upon the PRISONER. He is afraid. She sits down close to him, as if to cut off escape.
[Low.] I wonder if she is here.
I wonder.
[With an effort bringing herself and the others back to her.] But don’t turn against me because I’m not this particular woman. What a detail that is. I am--those victims of men’s dreadful--[Turns away her face] need for nobility. I’d rather die than go back to it! Help me to lead another life!
[Fervently.] We must lift her up.
We will find a place for her in the great good world outside the shielded life.
Then you others go, and I will stay.
MOTHERLY ONE and SCORNFUL ONE rise and move to the door.
I will give my life for yours, my sister!
No you won’t. I’ll have nothing to do with saving you. You deserve nothing better than woman’s honor. Come with us.
But at the door these three stand looking back at the CHEATED ONE.
[Moving down to her.] Aren’t you coming with us?
[Without raising her eyes.] No.
Why not?
I shall stay.
Perhaps she is here. And if “she” is here--then we have not the right to leave her.
Indicating the SHIELDED ONE.
[To CHEATED ONE.] Tell us: are you the woman Gordon Wallace was with on the night of October 25?
Yes.
Of course we’ve all said that.
But she says it in a different way.
[To SHIELDED ONE.] I am afraid that you will have to leave with us. It seems she has the right.
These four move to the door.
[Thinking of it just in time.] But do you think she has the right just because she is the one?
To consider this, they go back and sit down.
Leave me!
[Wickedly inspired.] Suppose we do! You know, I like the idea. Why--the more I think about it--the better I like it. [To the other women.] Yes, come! [To the young man.] This is the lady you were going to die for!
[Distressed.] But, no! What can it do for her? And how, through her, can we reach my poor sisters smothered under woman’s honor? I insist upon it! I am the one!
[Suddenly turning upon her.] You are not the one!
Now I think, to avoid feeling between you two, I had better stay. I’m a nurse, and a mother, and I keep coming back to the idea these things are needed.
No, you have too many other things to do. I am the one to remain. I am--peculiarly fitted for it.
You are not fitted for it at all. There is no one less fitted for it than you.
How do you make that out?
You don’t need it. Woman’s honor never hurt you.
[Reluctantly accepting this. To PRISONER.] Are you acquainted with this woman?
Indicates CHEATED ONE.
No.
Then why are you so afraid of her?
I’m not
But he is forced to meet the smoldering eye of the CHEATED ONE; he cannot look away.
[Almost in tears.] But you were going to help me lead a better life. And now you stand here quibbling over a petty question of fact, when the whole great question of escape from woman’s honor is at stake! Oh, is it true that women will not help one another? That they are hard and self-seeking?
She breaks down; MOTHERLY ONE goes to comfort her.
My heart is full
Your heart is full of a simpering parrot!
The LAWYER returns.
Ladies--ladies--quarreling? I’m sorry to find you in this mood. I had hoped while you were here together you might--arrive at some understanding.
[To SILLY ONE.] I wish you’d go home. We might arrive at something if we didn’t have you on our backs.
Now why must women always dislike each other?
[In her motherly way.] If I were you I’d try not to talk much.
Why not?
She has a kind heart. Now I--I’d let you talk.
Sometimes it seems quite as well not to try to follow women.
Sometimes even better.
Well now, Ladies, let us drop personal dissentions for the moment. This unfortunate young man, Mr. Wallace, is much moved by your generosity. He had made up his mind to die for woman’s honor. Now it seems he is not to do so--a change of plan to which he has not yet adjusted himself. His perturbation makes him unequal to selecting the lady who was with him on the night of October 25. [Door swings, PRISONER looks around nervously.] So--I would like to get your feeling. Since it seems unnecessary for all of you to have been with the young man on the night of October 25
Again door swings.
[In a rasped voice.] Could that door be closed? It makes me--nervous.
MOTHERLY WOMAN closes the door.
Now, doubtless you will agree with me that we should always eliminate waste. If a woman’s honor is to be sacrificed, may I without indelicacy inquire who would sacrifice least?
[Firmly.] I would.
[Weakly.] You would?
[In a voice dull as destiny.] The rest of you can talk as long as you like. I shall stay.
She rises and takes firm hold of the unfortunate young man’s chair.
Well, there seems something final about that.
Tell us, are you the one?
I am the one to stay.
Now, don’t cheat. Tell us, are you
[Passion flaming through sullenness.] Cheat? Cheat? You say to me, don’t cheat? I don’t cheat. I’ve been cheated. Cheated out of my chance to have a man I wanted by a man who would have what he wanted. Then he saved my woman’s honor. Married me and cheated me out of my life. I’m just something to be cheated. That’s the way I think of myself. Until this morning. Until I read about Gordon Wallace. Then I saw a way to get away from myself. It’s the first thing I ever wanted to do that I’ve done. You’ll not cheat me out of this. Don’t you try!
But she is thinking of it in just a personal way.
That’s why I stay.
But think of my poor sisters! All those unfortunate women
The only unfortunate woman I’ll think about is myself.
[Wildly.] You hear her? The only unfortunate woman she’ll think about
[Approaching CHEATED ONE.] Now we really must ask you
Love is so beautiful!
You can’t cheat just because you’ve been cheated.
[Inflamed--incoherent.] You say cheat to me again? You say cheat to
[Stepping in to pacify.] Ladies--ladies. Surely there must be a way out of the difficulty. Perhaps we can work out some way to
To save both of them through Gordon Wallace!
All women except CHEATED ONE draw together excitedly. The PRISONER, who has rapidly been approaching the breaking point makes a move as if he must try to escape. The CHEATED ONE is watching the other women.
Here! Yes! On the night of October 25
Their heads together in low-voiced conference with LAWYER. Suddenly the PRISONER slips around the CHEATED ONE--trying now not to be cheated of what is being said--and makes for the door. It opens in his face, and the doorway is blocked by a large and determined woman. PRISONER staggers back to LAWYER’S arms.
Oh, hell. I’ll plead guilty.
CURTAIN

Close the Bookby Susan GlaspellA young woman who believes she was born a gypsy is engaged into a proud old university-town family.
The Peopleby Susan GlaspellThe staff of a struggling radical paper are ready to give up, until three readers walk in from far away.
Suppressed Desiresby Susan GlaspellA woman who can't stop psychoanalysing everyone finds out what her husband and sister really want.
Tickless Timeby Susan GlaspellA couple in Provincetown bury their clocks to live by a sundial, and soon want them back.