Linesmith is still being forged.

linesmithby Joshua Bosman

Duologue from The Proposal by Anton Chekhov

Lomov and Natalya: “Oxen Meadows are ours, not yours!”

Lomov has come to propose to Natalya. Before he can get the words out, they fall into a quarrel about who owns a meadow between their estates.

  • 5 min 30 sec
  • Comic
  • Lomov: Man, 30 to 40
  • Natalya Stepanovna: Woman, 22 to 30
Read the whole scene
The play staged as expressionism, one of three stagings in a night (Vassar Experimental Theatre, 1927).
The play staged as expressionism, one of three stagings in a night. Photograph by Margaret DeMott Brown, from the 1928 Vassarion. Public domain, from Wikimedia Commons.

The play

LOMOV

I shall try to be brief. You must know, honoured Natalya Stepanovna, that I have long, since my childhood, in fact, had the privilege of knowing your family. My late aunt and her husband, from whom, as you know, I inherited my land, always had the greatest respect for your father and your late mother. The Lomovs and the Chubukovs have always had the most friendly, and I might almost say the most affectionate, regard for each other. And, as you know, my land is a near neighbour of yours. You will remember that my Oxen Meadows touch your birchwoods.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Excuse my interrupting you. You say, “my Oxen Meadows....” But are they yours?

LOMOV

Yes, mine.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

What are you talking about? Oxen Meadows are ours, not yours!

LOMOV

No, mine, honoured Natalya Stepanovna.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Well, I never knew that before. How do you make that out?

LOMOV

How? I’m speaking of those Oxen Meadows which are wedged in between your birchwoods and the Burnt Marsh.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Yes, yes.... They’re ours.

LOMOV

No, you’re mistaken, honoured Natalya Stepanovna, they’re mine.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Just think, Ivan Vassilevitch! How long have they been yours?

LOMOV

How long? As long as I can remember.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Really, you won’t get me to believe that!

LOMOV

But you can see from the documents, honoured Natalya Stepanovna. Oxen Meadows, it’s true, were once the subject of dispute, but now everybody knows that they are mine. There’s nothing to argue about. You see, my aunt’s grandmother gave the free use of these Meadows in perpetuity to the peasants of your father’s grandfather, in return for which they were to make bricks for her. The peasants belonging to your father’s grandfather had the free use of the Meadows for forty years, and had got into the habit of regarding them as their own, when it happened that...

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

No, it isn’t at all like that! Both my grandfather and great-grandfather reckoned that their land extended to Burnt Marsh--which means that Oxen Meadows were ours. I don’t see what there is to argue about. It’s simply silly!

LOMOV

I’ll show you the documents, Natalya Stepanovna!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

No, you’re simply joking, or making fun of me.... What a surprise! We’ve had the land for nearly three hundred years, and then we’re suddenly told that it isn’t ours! Ivan Vassilevitch, I can hardly believe my own ears.... These Meadows aren’t worth much to me. They only come to five dessiatins [Note: 13.5 acres], and are worth perhaps 300 roubles [Note: £30.], but I can’t stand unfairness. Say what you will, but I can’t stand unfairness.

LOMOV

Hear me out, I implore you! The peasants of your father’s grandfather, as I have already had the honour of explaining to you, used to bake bricks for my aunt’s grandmother. Now my aunt’s grandmother, wishing to make them a pleasant...

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

I can’t make head or tail of all this about aunts and grandfathers and grandmothers! The Meadows are ours, and that’s all.

LOMOV

Mine.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Ours! You can go on proving it for two days on end, you can go and put on fifteen dress-jackets, but I tell you they’re ours, ours, ours! I don’t want anything of yours and I don’t want to give up anything of mine. So there!

LOMOV

Natalya Ivanovna, I don’t want the Meadows, but I am acting on principle. If you like, I’ll make you a present of them.

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

I can make you a present of them myself, because they’re mine! Your behaviour, Ivan Vassilevitch, is strange, to say the least! Up to this we have always thought of you as a good neighbour, a friend: last year we lent you our threshing-machine, although on that account we had to put off our own threshing till November, but you behave to us as if we were gipsies. Giving me my own land, indeed! No, really, that’s not at all neighbourly! In my opinion, it’s even impudent, if you want to know....

LOMOV

Then you make out that I’m a land-grabber? Madam, never in my life have I grabbed anybody else’s land, and I shan’t allow anybody to accuse me of having done so.... [Quickly steps to the carafe and drinks more water] Oxen Meadows are mine!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

It’s not true, they’re ours!

LOMOV

Mine!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

It’s not true! I’ll prove it! I’ll send my mowers out to the Meadows this very day!

LOMOV

What?

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

My mowers will be there this very day!

LOMOV

I’ll give it to them in the neck!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

You dare!

LOMOV

[Clutches at his heart] Oxen Meadows are mine! You understand? Mine!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Please don’t shout! You can shout yourself hoarse in your own house, but here I must ask you to restrain yourself!

LOMOV

If it wasn’t, madam, for this awful, excruciating palpitation, if my whole inside wasn’t upset, I’d talk to you in a different way! [Yells] Oxen Meadows are mine!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Ours!

LOMOV

Mine!

NATALYA STEPANOVNA

Ours!

LOMOV

Mine!

The Proposal by Anton Chekhov: Translated by Julius West (1916). Public domain.

More duologues for a woman and a man